Most people are concerned or frightened by the growth of Islam and terrorism, but the church is called to have love and compassion for Muslims. Our primary response should not be fearful or political, but based on deep love and compassion to share the love of Jesus with every Muslim.
Most people do not reach Muslims because of fear. That fear takes three primary forms:
Fear of suffering. There is a strong fear of violence and suffering when most people consider engaging Muslims.
Fear of the questions. Muslims are typically trained and prepared to ask very aggressive questions. Most believers do not feel confident enough to answer them.
Fear of the unknown. Most believers do not feel like they understand Islam enough to challenge it directly and are afraid to engage.
Though the issue seems to be Islam, what these fears really expose is that many of us are not truly discipled. True disciples love Jesus wholeheartedly. Because they love Him above all, they do not fear what any person can do to them — they refuse to fear Muslims. Instead, they are a faithful witness of the gospel in all the world.
Islam itself is not the actual reason why we do not reach Muslims — lack of discipleship is. The ultimate solution to mobilizing the church to reach Muslims is to disciple people to follow Jesus.